Moving to New York from Indiana

moving to

What to Expect

Everything you need to know before relocating from Indiana to New York — costs, safety, healthcare, and practical first steps.

If you moved from Indiana to New York, you would find that New York is 37.0% more expensive than Indiana. A $75,000 salary in Indiana would need to be roughly $103,000 in New York to maintain the same lifestyle. Indianapolis and New York City are about 640 mi apart.

Thinking of moving to New York? Get a shortlist of towns in New York that match your priorities: size, cost, taxes, safety, disaster risk, hospitals and transport. Find my towns →

Is New York cheaper than Indiana?

Where you'll feel the difference day-to-day

Restaurants

pay 23.8% more

Groceries

pay 25.5% more

Transportation

pay 32.8% more

Housing

pay 53.7% more

Childcare

pay 56.9% more

Entertainment and Sports

pay 40.2% more

See full cost of living breakdown

Data: MyLifeElsewhere's crowdsourced cost of living database, with prices submitted and updated by users worldwide. Exchange rates are refreshed regularly from public sources.

What salary do you need in New York?

What does your salary buy?

$75,000 → $103,000

To maintain the same standard of living in New York

Calculate with your salary →

Cost of living by city

Cost of living varies a lot by city. Each figure is a city's overall cost of living as a percentage of New York City (the priciest, = 100%).

On average, cities in New York cost about 31% more than cities in Indiana.

Compare cities head-to-head

Key Indicator Comparison

Key indicators for anyone considering a move from Indiana to New York.

Is it safe?

Violent crime rate FBI Uniform Crime Reporting, 2023

incidents per 100,000 people per year

IN
327
NY
381
Property crime rate FBI Uniform Crime Reporting, 2023

incidents per 100,000 people per year

IN
1519
NY
1760

Indiana performs better than New York across all safety metrics.

How's the healthcare?

Uninsured rate US Census Bureau (American Community Survey), 2023

share of people without health insurance

IN
7.3%
NY
5.0%
Adult obesity rate Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (PLACES), 2022

share of adults with obesity

IN
38.5%
NY
29.9%

New York performs significantly better than Indiana across all health & wellbeing metrics.

What about housing?

Median home value US Census Bureau (American Community Survey), 2023

typical price of a home

IN
$201,600
NY
$403,000
Median rent US Census Bureau (American Community Survey), 2023

typical monthly gross rent

IN
$1,020
NY
$1,576

Indiana performs better than New York across all what about housing? metrics.

Will I have good infrastructure?

Internet access US Census Bureau (American Community Survey), 2023

share of households with internet

IN
88.5%
NY
89.7%
Average commute US Census Bureau (American Community Survey), 2023

minutes each way to work

IN
24 min
NY
33 min

Indiana generally does better on infrastructure, though New York leads in internet access.

What are the job prospects?

Unemployment rate Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2025

percentage of the labour force without work

IN
2.7%
NY
4.4%
GDP per capita Bureau of Economic Analysis, 2024

a broad measure of economic output per person

IN
$59,083
NY
$91,992

Indiana generally does better on employment & economy, though New York leads in gdp per capita.

Is it good for families?

Life expectancy OECD Regional Demography, 2020

average years of life at birth

IN
75.0 yrs
NY
77.7 yrs
Bachelor's degree or higher US Census Bureau (American Community Survey), 2023

share of adults with a 4-year college degree

IN
19%
NY
28%

New York performs significantly better than Indiana across all family life metrics.

Weather in New York vs Indiana

Monthly averages — select a city to compare.

Indianapolis Rain: 40.8 in/yr (1036 mm)
62° / 44°F

Avg. annual high / low

New York City Rain: 49.9 in/yr (1268 mm)
62° / 48°F

Avg. annual high / low

Months Indianapolis New York City
Jan–Mar 42°/26°F (6°/-3°C) 43°/30°F (6°/-1°C)
Apr–Jun 72°/53°F (22°/12°C) 70°/54°F (21°/12°C)
Jul–Sep 81°/63°F (27°/17°C) 81°/66°F (27°/19°C)
Oct–Dec 51°/35°F (11°/2°C) 54°/41°F (12°/5°C)
View all months
Month Indianapolis New York City
Jan 35°/21°F (1.7°/-6.1°C) 38°/27°F (3.5°/-2.8°C)
Feb 40°/24°F (4.4°/-4.4°C) 42°/29°F (5.3°/-1.7°C)
Mar 51°/33°F (10.8°/0.8°C) 50°/35°F (9.8°/1.8°C)
Apr 63°/44°F (17.1°/6.4°C) 61°/45°F (16.2°/7.1°C)
May 72°/53°F (22.5°/11.7°C) 71°/54°F (21.6°/12.2°C)
Jun 81°/63°F (27.4°/17.4°C) 79°/64°F (26.3°/17.6°C)
Jul 84°/67°F (28.8°/19.2°C) 84°/69°F (28.9°/20.4°C)
Aug 83°/65°F (28.4°/18.3°C) 83°/68°F (28.1°/19.9°C)
Sep 77°/57°F (25.1°/13.9°C) 75°/61°F (24.0°/16.0°C)
Oct 64°/45°F (18.0°/7.3°C) 64°/50°F (17.7°/10.0°C)
Nov 52°/36°F (11.0°/2.3°C) 54°/42°F (12.1°/5.3°C)
Dec 38°/25°F (3.6°/-3.9°C) 43°/32°F (6.1°/0.0°C)

Data: National Weather Service National Weather Service

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it cheaper to live in New York than Indiana?

No — New York is on average about 37% more expensive than Indiana. City-level variation matters.

How much money do I need to move to New York?

Plan for at least 3 months of living expenses — roughly $25,750 in New York on a $75,000 comparable salary — plus one-off moving costs (movers, a truck rental, and a rental deposit).

Is New York safe?

Indiana performs better than New York across all safety metrics.

How is healthcare in New York compared to Indiana?

New York performs significantly better than Indiana across all health & wellbeing metrics.

What's the weather like in New York compared to Indiana?

The average high temperature in New York City is 62°F, compared to 62°F in Indianapolis. New York City receives around 49.9 in of rainfall per year, while Indianapolis gets 40.8 in.

Share this