Cost of living comparison
compared to
New York City vs. Charlotte Amalie Cost of Living Summary
New York City is 28.7% more expensive than Charlotte Amalie.
New York City vs. Charlotte Amalie Cost Breakdown
If you lived in New York City instead of Charlotte Amalie, you would:
pay 11.5% more for restaurants
|
Charlotte Amalie
|
New York City
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Basic meal with drink at inexpensive restaurant |
$25.00
|
$26.50
|
|
|
Fast food combo meal
McDonalds, or similar
|
$13.00
|
$14.50
|
|
| Bottle of Coca-Cola (11 fl. oz) |
$3.00
|
$3.95
|
|
| Bottle of water (11 fl. oz) |
$2.50
|
$2.97
|
|
Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City - Cost of restaurants
pay 39.3% less for groceries
|
Charlotte Amalie
|
New York City
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
|
Bread
1 loaf
|
$9.00
|
$4.78
|
|
| Local cheese (8 oz) | ?? |
$9.47
|
|
| Milk (1 gallon) |
$10.50
|
$5.13
|
|
|
Eggs
1 dozen
|
$7.00
|
$6.03
|
|
| Boneless chicken breast (1 lb) | ?? |
$7.93
|
|
| Apples (1 lb) | ?? |
$3.11
|
|
| Bananas (1 lb) | ?? |
$0.96
|
|
| Oranges (1 lb) | ?? |
$2.83
|
|
| Tomatoes (1 lb) | ?? |
$3.08
|
|
| Potatoes (1 lb) | ?? |
$1.83
|
|
| Onions (1 lb) | ?? |
$2.04
|
|
Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City - Cost of groceries
pay 17.4% less for transportation
|
Charlotte Amalie
|
New York City
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Gasoline (1 gallon) |
$5.00
|
$4.31
|
|
| Monthly public transit pass | ?? |
$140.00
|
|
| New Volkswagen Golf 1.4 (standard edition) |
$45,000.00
|
$35,458.00
|
|
| Taxi trip in downtown area (5 miles) | ?? |
$20.44
|
|
Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City - Cost of transportation
pay 2.5 times more for housing
|
Charlotte Amalie
|
New York City
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
|
Internet connection
50 mbps or faster, cable/dsl
|
$100.00
|
$71.57
|
|
| 1-Bedroom apartment in downtown area |
$1,250.00
|
$4,447.32
|
|
| 1-Bedroom apartment outside city center |
$1,000.00
|
$3,217.65
|
|
|
Utilities for two
(700 sq ft apartment)
including electric, gas, water, heating
|
$227.50
|
$164.80
|
|
Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City - Cost of housing
pay (unknown) more for childcare
|
Charlotte Amalie
|
New York City
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Private preschool for 1 child, monthly | ?? |
$3,379.10
|
|
| Middle school for 1 child, two semesters | ?? |
$60,882.67
|
Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City - Cost of childcare
pay 25.7% more for entertainment and sports
|
Charlotte Amalie
|
New York City
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
| Domestic/local beer (1 pint) |
$5.50
|
$8.50
|
|
| Cappuccino in mid-range area |
$7.33
|
$6.50
|
|
|
Pack of cigarettes
Marlboro or similar
|
$5.00
|
$19.00
|
|
| Monthly membership at local gym |
$200.00
|
$121.41
|
|
| Movie ticket to theater/cinema |
$12.00
|
$22.50
|
|
Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City - Cost of entertainment and sports
pay 33.8% more for clothing
|
Charlotte Amalie
|
New York City
|
||
|---|---|---|---|
|
Regular jeans
Levi's brand
|
?? |
$75.86
|
|
|
Regular dress
from H&M or similar store
|
?? |
$54.45
|
|
|
Running shoes
Nike or Adidas
|
$90.00
|
$120.38
|
|
| Men's business shoes (leather) | ?? |
$132.00
|
|
Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City - Cost of clothing
We average the price of thousands of data points entered by users across the world. Sources: MyLifeElsewhere's cost-of-living dataset (prices updated October 2026). How we calculate this
Change currency:
Compare further: Charlotte Amalie vs. New York City
Compare countries by overall cost of living
See the
cost of living in Virgin Islands vs. United States.
This provides a comparison of the average cost of living from cities within Virgin Islands and United States.
Help us improve these prices
MyLifeElsewhere is a collaborative project. Please enter price information for your location to help assist us in making these comparisons more accurate.
Learn more
Ask the Elsewhere Community
Join the Elsewhere community and ask a question about New York City or Charlotte Amalie. It's a free, question-and-answer based forum to discuss what life is like in countries and cities around the world.